
Israeli military kept secret animal project running for years despite doubts over its value
According to an investigation by Yossi Melman in The Seventh Eye, the initiative is estimated to have cost around NIS 1 billion, with animals rarely assigned operational missions. The report also recounts allegations of corruption and retaliation against two employees who raised concerns.
Israel’s defense establishment has spent more than NIS 1 billion maintaining a secretive project involving animals for security purposes, despite the initiative having little operational use, according to an investigation published Tuesday by Israeli journalist Yossi Melman in The Seventh Eye.
The project, which was run by veterans of an elite IDF unit who received specialized training, continued for years under a veil of secrecy. Its costs included animal maintenance and veterinary care, training personnel and purchasing specialized equipment, Melman reported. The investigation said that, with only a handful of exceptions, the animals were rarely assigned operational missions.
The estimate of the project's cost comes from a former member of the initiative identified only as H., who told Melman that he believed it had cost approximately NIS 1 billion since its establishment. The report also describes the expenditure as having exceeded that amount.
Despite questions about its effectiveness, the project was not shut down. According to the investigation, a decision was made several years ago to scale back the operation and eventually close it, but the plan was never implemented. Military personnel and civilians continued to maintain the project and its staff at public expense.
The report also describes allegations of corruption and financial mismanagement dating back to the project's early days. H., one of the initiative's original participants, told Melman that he and another member, identified as G., became concerned that the officer overseeing the project was mixing its activities with private business dealings involving outside suppliers.
H. said that when they raised their concerns with senior defense officials and the defense establishment's comptroller, the allegations were not properly investigated. Instead, he claimed, the two men were accused of leaking classified information and making baseless allegations against their commander, before being dismissed in retaliation.
"Instead of investigating the suspicions of corruption, they investigated us and leveled false accusations against us," H. said.
The dispute eventually reached then-Defense Minister and Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, who imposed a gag order on the affair, according to the report. H. and G. subsequently pursued a public and legal campaign that lasted eight years. Melman reported that their names were eventually cleared and they received significant compensation, although the secrecy surrounding the project remained in place.
The initiative was initially conceived as an effort to improve Israel's defensive capabilities, drawing on similar programs used by major militaries, according to The Seventh Eye. The idea was reportedly rejected at first by a defense minister who argued that the defense establishment was not a "zoo," but was revived after he left office.
Melman reported that the project was initiated by a former member of an elite military unit who had business ties to a senior defense official. The report also describes how personnel involved in procuring equipment later raised concerns about the conduct of the officer managing the initiative.
Over the years, the project became the subject of demonstrations for senior defense officials, some of which H. described as little more than entertainment. He compared the visits to a circus, saying the personnel involved were effectively performers putting on a show for visiting commanders.
According to Melman, some senior commanders came to believe that the initiative, in its existing form, had no meaningful value. Others reportedly argued that making its existence public could itself serve as a deterrent. Nevertheless, the project continued operating.
The existence of the initiative was disclosed following a lengthy legal effort by Melman, assisted by Elad Man, legal counsel for the Hatzlacha organization. The publication was approved as a compromise by the Committee of Three, an appellate body for Military Censor decisions chaired by former Supreme Court Justice Ayala Procaccia. Its other members are retired Brigadier General Itai Brun, representing the defense establishment, and media representative Shalom Kital.
Melman said that journalist Ran Edelist of Maariv had also pursued the story in its earlier stages, but that previous efforts to publish it had been blocked by the defense establishment's security apparatus and the Military Censor.
The report does not disclose the specific animals involved or the precise operational purpose of the project, reflecting the restrictions imposed on the publication. It does, however, raise questions about how an initiative that senior officials reportedly regarded as ineffective was allowed to continue for years, with its costs borne by taxpayers.














