The City of London

The job market is freezing up, and economists fear the damage could last for years

Hiring and resignations are slowing in the U.S. and U.K., limiting workers' ability to move up and employers' ability to recruit talent. The consequences could be particularly severe for young people trying to enter the workforce.

Economists and policymakers in the U.K. and the United States are warning that the current state of their labor markets could cause long-term damage to productivity, the Financial Times reported. The situation is characterized by a "slowdown in both hiring and resignations," meaning that employers are recruiting fewer workers while employees are also less inclined to leave their jobs. In the United States, hiring, resignations and job-switching are all near their lowest levels in a decade, excluding the COVID-19 period. In the U.K., the share of people changing jobs each quarter has fallen to levels comparable to those seen in the aftermath of the 2008 global financial crisis.
The lack of worker mobility is particularly concerning because both countries are generally characterized by flexible labor markets, with relatively few obstacles to hiring and firing. "In the United States especially, moving between jobs is considered a way to move up the ranks, a way to get a promotion or a raise," said Claudia Sahm, a former economist at the Federal Reserve.
Uncertainty surrounding factors such as tariffs, advances in AI and the broader economic outlook is contributing to the slowdown, discouraging both employees and employers from taking risks.
1 View gallery
הסיטי של לונדון
הסיטי של לונדון
The City of London
(The City of London, Toby Melville)
Sahm warned that the lack of job openings could cause lasting damage to productivity if young people are unable to enter the workforce or fully develop their skills. "It could be expensive in the long run, and devastating for people who are at the beginning of their careers, if already at this stage they are knocked off the ladder," she said.
Employers are missing out on vital skills
The issue has also featured in discussions among central bankers, particularly as they assess the outlook for interest rates. Their concern is that the lack of movement in labor markets is unusual at a time of relatively stable economic activity and low unemployment.
Experts argue that high worker turnover has historically been a key factor behind the "extraordinary performance of the U.S. economy" compared with European economies.
A similar warning came from the Bank of England. Clare Lombardelli, its Deputy Governor for Monetary Policy, cautioned last week that the British labor market is "stuck in low gear" and has become less effective at "moving people toward new opportunities." She argued that this weakens productivity and makes it harder for the economy to adopt AI, as workers miss out on opportunities to advance while companies struggle to acquire the skills they need.
The European Central Bank has also expressed concern about the trend. A study published by the bank last year identified "low dynamism" as a key factor behind Europe's underperformance in the high-tech sector, where, according to the study, "creative destruction requires the flexible reallocation of resources."
Stefano Scarpetta, who heads the OECD's Directorate for Employment, Labour and Social Affairs, summed up the issue: "To improve labor productivity growth, existing firms must undergo restructuring, and start-ups must be able to scale up. It all hinges on the mobility of workers."
Youth unemployment rises in the U.K.
The British government has announced an expansion of a program designed to guarantee employment for young people, Reuters reported, as it seeks to address rising youth unemployment. In the second quarter of the year, 981,000 people aged 16 to 24 in the U.K. were not in employment, education or training, representing 13% of that age group and the second-highest rate in Europe.
According to a government statement, the program guarantees a job to eligible young people in this age group who receive Universal Credit. It will be expanded nationwide from the end of this month and could assist more than 90,000 people. From April, eligibility will be extended to those who have been receiving the benefit for 12 months, down from the current 18-month requirement. The program provides government-funded paid employment for 25 hours a week over six months.
"The longer someone is out of the workforce, the harder it becomes for them to re-enter it. We must not leave any young person behind, without an employment opportunity," said Pat McFadden, Secretary of State for Work and Pensions.
The government's decision comes ahead of the publication this week of a report by Alan Milburn, a former minister and close associate of Labour Prime Minister Andy Burnham. The report will examine the reasons behind the rising number of young people who are neither employed nor in education, and set out recommendations for helping more of them enter the labor market. Among the proposals are removing the additional unemployment benefit payments currently granted to people aged 25 and under on health grounds, and moving them to a more restricted tier of the U.K.'s main disability benefit.