
Analysis
Israel’s inflation falls to 1.1%, putting pressure on the Bank of Israel to cut rates
The October CPI unexpectedly declined by 0.1%, bringing annual inflation close to the bottom of the central bank’s target range. The data strengthen the case for a rate cut, but volatile travel prices and geopolitical risks could still give policymakers pause.
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) released Sunday evening by the Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS) is another instance of economic data catching forecasters off guard. This was one of the most significant inflation surprises in recent times, raising questions about the price environment and the direction of monetary policy in Israel. Instead of the 0.3% monthly increase widely anticipated by the market, the October index fell by 0.1%. As a result, annual inflation dropped to just 1.1%, well below the 1.5% expected. Even the lowest forecast, at 1.3%, was higher than the actual figure.
This is the lowest inflation rate since April 2021. Perhaps more significantly, inflation in Israel is now just 0.1 percentage points above the lower bound of the government's price stability target range of 1% to 3%. Another negative surprise could push it below that threshold. This does not mean the economy is already experiencing deflation, which is a sustained decline in the overall price level. But the implications for monetary policy are clear: the Bank of Israel must now also consider the risk that inflation could become too low.
Some answers may emerge on Monday, when the CBS releases its third-quarter economic growth data. Economists will be looking for signs that a slowdown is taking hold. According to economic theory, weaker demand is generally associated with easing inflationary pressure, although a decline in inflation alone does not necessarily indicate an economic slowdown.
To understand what happened in October, it is necessary to look beyond the headline figure. The category that had the greatest impact on the index was travel abroad and domestic flights. Prices in this category fell by 5.1%, subtracting 0.23 percentage points from the index on their own. In other words, without this category, the index would have risen by approximately 0.13% rather than falling by 0.1%. Owner-occupied housing services, which recorded a 0.5% decline, subtracted a further 0.085 percentage points. Together, the two components reduced the index by 0.32 percentage points. Excluding their impact, the index would have risen by 0.22%.
This is an important distinction in understanding the surprise. A significant portion of the decline came from just two categories, one of which, travel abroad, is particularly volatile and subject to substantial seasonal fluctuations. Other prices also moved in opposite directions. Fresh fruit prices fell by 2.8%, while accommodation, vacations and travel costs declined by 2.4%. By contrast, clothing and footwear prices rose by 4.1%, and fresh vegetables became 3.5% more expensive.
But the more revealing figures emerge when seasonal effects are taken into account. Even after seasonal adjustment, the CPI fell by 0.3% in October. The seasonally adjusted index excluding housing, vegetables and fruit dropped by 0.4%, while the index excluding housing fell by 0.5%. These measures still include travel abroad, making it impossible to fully isolate the impact of that category. Nevertheless, they suggest that the surprise cannot be explained solely by the usual seasonal declines.
Trend data from the CBS point to annualized inflation of just 0.9% between July and October. The index excluding housing registered an annualized decline of 0.3%, while the index excluding housing, fruit and vegetables fell by 0.6%. These figures do not represent the actual change in prices over the past 12 months; rather, they extrapolate the trend observed in recent months. Still, they suggest that the moderation in prices may extend beyond a single month's reading.
The 12-month figures reinforce that picture. The CPI excluding energy rose by just 1% over the past year, while the index excluding housing declined by 0.1%. That is an unusual result, suggesting that, outside the housing component, the overall price level of the consumption basket is slightly lower than it was a year ago.
All this is happening at a time when several economic forces might have been expected to push prices in the opposite direction. First, the weakening of the shekel is an inflationary force par excellence, as a weaker currency typically raises the cost of imports. At the same time, the industrial Producer Price Index (PPI) surged by 1.9% in October and by 5.1% over the past year. The index of residential construction inputs also rose, increasing by 0.4% in October and 3.9% over the year, as wages in the sector climbed by 5.2%. On the face of it, there is a contradiction: input costs are rising and the currency is weakening, yet consumer prices are falling.
The contradiction, however, is only partial. Excluding fuel, the PPI was unchanged in October and rose by just 0.9% over the past year. The sharp increase in the headline index was largely driven by energy prices, particularly refined petroleum products, which became 16.5% more expensive in a single month. In other words, even on the production side, there is little evidence of a broad-based inflationary surge. Nor should rising construction costs be directly equated with consumer inflation. Construction inputs belong to a different market, are subject to different pricing mechanisms and can take time to feed through to consumer prices.
That brings us to the question of the exchange rate. Why has the weakening of the shekel not translated more clearly into higher consumer prices? One possible explanation is that the pass-through from exchange rates to prices takes time. Another is that importers and retailers are finding it difficult to pass higher costs on to consumers, forcing them to absorb some of the increase through lower profit margins. If that is the case, it could point to weaker domestic demand than forecasters had anticipated, a particularly concerning possibility.
The housing market presents another complicated picture. The owner-occupied housing services component fell by 0.5%, yet rents on renewed contracts rose by approximately 2.8% year-on-year, while rents for apartments that changed tenants increased by 5.5%. Meanwhile, housing prices themselves continue to decline, falling by 1.5% annually, including a 2.1% drop in the Tel Aviv district. Prices of new apartments fell by 0.7%. The result is a market in which property values are declining, construction costs are rising, and parts of the rental market continue to experience upward price pressure.
From a macroeconomic perspective, the most significant implication of the latest CPI reading concerns the Bank of Israel's next interest rate decision. The central bank, which held its benchmark rate at 3.25% last month, now faces annual inflation of just 1.1%. The gap between the nominal interest rate and the annual inflation rate is 2.15 percentage points. This is not the expected real interest rate, which is calculated using inflation expectations rather than past inflation. Nevertheless, the gap illustrates how restrictive monetary policy may look in light of the latest data.
The latest reading has strengthened the case for an interest rate cut at the next decision, scheduled for November 23. A quarter-percentage-point reduction, which would bring the rate down to 3%, is now a more compelling possibility. The Bank of Israel could still argue that it would be unwise to infer a long-term trend from a single data point, particularly when travel abroad accounted for such a large share of the monthly decline. A cautious approach would also take into account other risks, including political deadlock, the fiscal outlook and, of course, geopolitical developments.
The question is not whether the Bank of Israel should ignore those risks, but whether it is giving sufficient weight to the opposite danger: maintaining a monetary policy that is too restrictive even as inflation approaches the lower end of the target range. The price stability target is symmetrical. Inflation below 1% is just as much a deviation from the target as inflation above 3%.
Until now, the Bank of Israel has been called upon to explain why interest rates can be lowered without jeopardizing price stability. Now, the Governor and his colleagues will also have to explain the economic cost of not lowering them.














